When truth falters, democracies begin to decay

The first casualty of democracy’s decline is truth. History shows that moral decay starts not with violence but with lies

Interview requests

Genocide doesn’t begin with killing. It begins when truth loses value, when people are divided into us and them, and when societies forget that moral strength is their most excellent defence against collapse. Truth is the oxygen of democracy, and when it thins, trust and humanity soon follow.

Gregory Stanton’s Ten Stages of Genocide, developed after studying atrocities in Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia, offers a chilling but useful warning. His stages, from classification and symbolization to persecution and denial, describe the moral and institutional decay that can occur anywhere when fear replaces empathy and truth is politicized.

History provides stark lessons. In Rwanda in 1994, roughly 800,000 people were killed in 100 days after years of propaganda and dehumanization turned neighbours into enemies. In Sudan’s Darfur region, ethnic cleansing and sexual violence, documented by international human rights bodies, have scarred the region for decades.

The Middle East, too, offers grim reminders. The Armenian genocide during the final years of the Ottoman Empire, in what is now Turkey, demonstrated how imperial collapse and dehumanization can feed each other. Nearly a century later, ISIS’s campaign against the Yazidis in Iraq revealed that propaganda and denial still drive atrocity when truth is silenced.

The same pattern can appear in powerful states. In China, the reported persecution of Uyghur Muslims, a Turkic ethnic minority in the Xinjiang region, documented by UN experts and human rights organizations, involves allegations of mass surveillance, detention camps and cultural erasure. When truth is suppressed and entire groups are labelled as threats, moral decay occurs not in chaos but through cold efficiency.

These examples from around the world reveal how moral collapse begins with the erosion of truth.

Canada and other democracies are not exempt from those same human tendencies. The warning signs are subtle: distrust of the media, contempt for institutions and the casual spread of disinformation. Once those take root, the space for reasoned debate shrinks and emotion replaces evidence as the driver of public life.

In the United States, polarization has reached levels unseen in generations. Competing media ecosystems reinforce division, while conspiracy theories and online extremism deepen mistrust. Yet the country’s civil institutions and free press still stand as vital counterweights.

Canada is also not immune. When governments or citizens begin to divide people into categories—citizens and non-citizens, rural and urban, left and right—we edge closer to Stanton’s early warning signs. Proposals such as marking citizenship on identification cards, as discussed in Alberta, may seem harmless but risk promoting subtle forms of exclusion. The Canadian Civil Liberties Association has warned that such measures could lead to unequal treatment and stigmatization.

History also teaches that dehumanization and denial flourish when truth is ignored. Yet truth can also heal. Canada’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission, created in 2008 to document the legacy of residential schools, produced 94 Calls to Action that show confronting injustice directly can strengthen rather than weaken a society’s moral foundation.

The choice facing both Canada and the U.S. is not between perfection and collapse but between vigilance and complacency. Democracies do not fall in a single moment; they erode through cynicism, division and the slow corrosion of shared values.

If we can resist the impulse to vilify those who disagree, protect institutions that safeguard fairness and commit again to truth as a public good, both our countries can emerge stronger. If we fail to do so, we will have no one to blame for democracy’s decay but ourselves.

Gerry Chidiac specializes in languages and genocide studies and works with at-risk students. He received an award from the Vancouver Holocaust Education Centre for excellence in teaching about the Holocaust.